In, The Edgar’s Creek Suspect Sighting, a special edition of the Melbourne Marvels and Who is Mr Cruel podcast collaboration, we take time out from telling the Karmein Chan story to discuss a recent meeting and interview Eamonn from Melbourne Marvels had with the witness David.
David had a staggering encounter with a suspicious man on the night of 13 April 1991, about 90 minutes after Karmein Chan was abducted from her Templestowe home by an unknown assailant.
That night David saw this suspect fire a gunshot at Edgar’s Creek in Reservoir, the same creek where Karmein’s remains were found on 9 April, 1992.
David has previously told this story on his Youtube channel, @australianews, in 2012. However, in this episode, Eamonn visits the site in question with David where we retrace his steps that night, and he reveals a few more intriguing details about his experience that day.

NB:- this podcast deals with topics of a serious nature. Sexual assault and murder are discussed.
For more information on Mr Cruel attacks please click on the following links.
Lower Plenty Attack
The abduction of Sharon Wills
The abduction of Nicola Lynas
Please also read up on Jay’s website www.whoismrcruel.com for more information about this case.
NB: The use of copyright material in this podcast is for fair dealing for research purposes, for criticism and for reporting news. Melbourne Marvels is a non-profit blog/podcast that is researching the unsolved crimes of ‘Mr Cruel’.
Warning, this episode contains details about the sexual assault of children and the murder of a child. Please use discretion before listening.
If you like to leave a comment to Melbourne Marvels, please fill out the form below.
Production by Elocra
If you would like to make a contribution to help offsets the costs incurred as part of Melbourne Marvels’ research, please fill out the below form.

